CSA Scores & Compliance
What is a compliance review and how is it different from a safety audit?
Updated September 1, 2026
A compliance review (CR) is an on-site examination of a carrier's records by an FMCSA safety investigator. Unlike a New Entrant Safety Audit, it can happen to any carrier at any time and covers a broader set of safety regulations.
What triggers a compliance review
- High CSA BASIC percentile scores
- A serious crash investigation
- A complaint about the carrier
- Randomly, as part of FMCSA's oversight program
What gets evaluated
A CR can include driver qualification files, vehicle maintenance, drug and alcohol programs, hours-of-service records, and financial responsibility (insurance). The scope depends on which BASICs triggered the review.
Possible outcomes
- Satisfactory — no significant issues found
- Conditional — certain deficiencies identified; corrective action required
- Unsatisfactory — serious violations found; can lead to operations out-of-service order
An Unsatisfactory rating that isn't corrected can lead to revocation of authority. If you receive a notice of a compliance review, treat it as urgent — a compliance specialist can help you prepare.
This is general orientation, not legal or regulatory advice. Requirements change and vary by operation — confirm specifics with the relevant agency or a qualified advisor before acting on them.
Still stuck?
Check your carrier record, or talk to a compliance specialist.